dill.fish

What is an HSA and why should I get one?

Every year you have to pick your health insurance, and every year you still don't know what an HSA is. I spent several years at Forma building HSAs for employees at companies like Robinhood, Block, and Toyota, so I have a lot of practice explaining them in straightforward language that doesn't make you want to bang your head against a wall. Here's the simplest possible rundown that I give to friends and family. These are my personal opinions, not financial advice.

What is an HSA?

An HSA is a bank account with special government-defined rules about what you can do with the money in the account, in exchange for special privileges on that money. It's a pretax benefit account included in a family of other benefits you've probably heard of like FSA, DCFSA, Commuter, and so on, which are programs created by the government to incentivize and help citizens save money for specific goals.

HSAs specifically are built for healthcare spending and are a triple tax advantaged account type. This means that the money you contribute to this account is not taxed when it goes in, it isn't taxed while it grows in the account, and it isn't taxed when you withdraw/spend from the account, as long as you spend the money on healthcare. This money can be used for healthcare at any time, even years after you have the plan - your contributions with a past employer and insurance provider still sit in that account forever, until you decide to use them. The definition of "healthcare" for these accounts is generous, and includes everything from traditional medical care to Eight Sleep mattresses to Fitbits. You can get a better idea of the full range at hsastore.com or by Googling any specific items or treatments you're interested in. Some health-related expenses, like gym memberships, aren't eligible unless you have a Letter of Medical Necessity from a doctor.

You said the money in my HSA isn't taxed while it grows. How does it grow?

One of the biggest upsides of the HSA is that, while conceptually it's a single account, behind the scenes it's two accounts: a cash/debit account plus a brokerage account. When you aren't spending the money sitting in your HSA account, you can invest it in the stock market like any other brokerage account, and your gains are tax-free. This, in particular, is what makes the HSA so revered among certain crowds - nearly all the C-suite execs at every company we served maxed out their contributions to use it as another kind of retirement account.

Are there any other advantages I should know about?

Yes! There's an exception to the rules above; after the age of 65, the healthcare spending rules go away, and you can withdraw/spend your HSA funds on anything at your normal income tax rate.

So what's the catch?

There are a few tradeoffs and rules to consider:

  1. HSAs can only be paired with High-Deductible Health Plans (HDHP)

    The main drawback for most people is that an HSA can only be paired with an HDHP, which is basically what it sounds like: a health insurance plan that has lower monthly payments, but a higher deductible. HDHP deductibles commonly range between $2,500 and $4,000, meaning you have to pay that much out-of-pocket before any insurance coverage kicks in - and there are no flat copays like you might find with other insurance plans. Even once the coverage kicks in, it's usually only partial, and you could end up paying a maximum of $8,700 (individual) or $17,400 (family) out-of-pocket.

  2. Contribution limits

    HSAs also limit how much you can contribute in a given year, and your employer's contributions count against this limit. In 2026, an individual can't contribute more than $4,400 for the year, and a family can't contribute more than $8,750.

  3. Conflicting coverage

    In order to open or contribute to an HSA, you can't have some other common types of healthcare coverage. You can't have Medicare, you can't be covered by a spouse's regular health insurance plan, and neither you or your spouse can have an FSA or HRA, even if you aren't using your spouse's accounts.

  4. Early use penalties

    If for any reason you end up using HSA funds for expenses not related to healthcare before the age of 65, you pay a 20% tax on that money in addition to your income tax.

How should I decide if an HSA is right for me?

Again, not financial advice, but I think there are really only two things to consider.

Can I afford it?

The first baseline consideration is simply the upfront cost. Plan for the worst scenario - if you elect an HSA and then get hit by a bus, could you afford the full out-of-pocket expense? If an unexpected $8,700 expense is going to cause you financial issues, an HSA may not be the right move until you build up your savings. You also need to consider that your contribution comes out of your paycheck, and many employers don't contribute much.

Does the math work?

The second is the math, which is pretty clearly in favor of the HSA in most scenarios. HDHP premiums are usually lower than traditional insurance plans, plus the HSA skips income and payroll taxes, so an HSA in a year without significant healthcare expenses is already ahead. It only starts to lose ground in a year with significant expenses, where the HDHP's higher deductible cost you more out-of-pocket.

But that loss is easily made back up thanks to your compounding investments. Here's a made-up example to demonstrate the point, using more-favorable-than-average numbers for the regular plan.

Regular planHDHP
Premiums you pay$150/month$100/month
Deductible$500$4,000
After the deductibleYou pay 20%You pay 20%
Out-of-pocket max$3,000$7,000
HSA contributionNone$4,500

The HDHP starts at a $1,950/yr advantage, thanks to the $600 in cheaper premiums, plus about $1,350 in tax savings on the $4,500 contribution, assuming a 30% tax rate.

With significant medical bills, here's how the comparison looks. The last column shows how long the $4,500 in your HSA would need to grow at a stock market annual average rate of 7% to make up the difference:

Medical bills this year You pay on regular plan You pay on HDHP HDHP costs extra After the $1,950 advantage Years of growth to earn it back
$500$500$500$0HDHP ahead $1,950Nothing to earn back
$2,000$800$2,000$1,200HDHP ahead $750Nothing to earn back
$5,000$1,400$4,200$2,800HDHP behind $8502.6
$15,000$3,000$6,200$3,200HDHP behind $1,2503.6
$20,000 or more$3,000$7,000$4,000HDHP behind $2,0505.5

Caveats: these payback calculations don't consider a tradeoff in which you have a regular plan and invest the comparable funds via a taxable brokerage account, which would reduce the HSA's advantage, but still lose. It also ignores copays for simplicity's sake.

TLDR:

What about FSAs?

FSAs are basically never better than HSAs. You can't invest the money in them, and they're use-it-or-lose-it: you can only rollover up to $700 in unused funds to the next year, and you lose it all if you part ways with your employer.

Compare your own plans

Enter the numbers for the two plans you're choosing between, and the table below works out what each one costs you at different levels of medical bills.

Regular planHDHP
Premiums you pay, per month $ $
Deductible $ $
You pay after the deductible % %
Out-of-pocket max $ $
Your HSA contribution, per year None $
Employer HSA contribution, per year None $
%

Federal and state income tax, plus 7.65% if your contributions come out of your paycheck

%

The stock market has averaged about 7% a year after inflation

Medical bills this year You pay on regular plan You pay on HDHP HDHP costs extra After the advantage Years of growth to earn it back

"You pay" is the deductible plus your share after it, up to the out-of-pocket max. Premiums are counted in the advantage. Years of growth assume you pay the bills from savings and the whole $4,500 in your HSA stays invested.

How long until the market earns back a healthcare expense?

$
$

Up to $8,700, the most an HDHP can make one person pay in a year

%

Paid from HSA Paid out-of-pocket Expense

Years after the expense

Assumes you contribute once, pay the expense right away, and invest whatever is left in the HSA, with growth compounding yearly. Paid out-of-pocket means the whole contribution stays invested.